[abc] [Fwd: OOPSLA 2005 Posters Notification (pp25)]

Seems this only went to the first six authors...

- P

-------- Original Message --------
Subject: OOPSLA 2005 Posters Notification (pp25)
Date: Wed, 3 Aug 2005 21:22:40 EDT
From: Dirk Siebert <posters@oopsla.org>
Reply-To: posters@oopsla.org
To: christopher.allan@some.ox.ac.uk, pavel.avgustinov@magd.ox.ac.uk,
aske@brics.dk, bruno.dufour@mail.mcgill.ca, cgoard@cs.mcgill.ca,
hendren@sable.mcgill.ca
CC: posters@oopsla.org, oopsla2005-posters-webadmin@borbala.com

Dear Chris, Pavel, Aske Simon, Bruno, Christopher and Laurie,

congratulations, your submission

"abc: The AspectBench Compiler for AspectJ (A WorkBench for Aspect-Oriented
Programming Language and Compilers Research)"

has been accepted for the OOPSLA 2005 Posters.

Attached, you will find the reviewers' comments. Please study them
carefully and adjust your poster and your abstract accordingly.

When preparing your extended abstract's final version, make sure, you
adhere to every and all requirements on
http://www.sheridanprinting.com/typedept/oopsla3.htm . Failure to do so
will result in your abstract not being included in the OOPSLA 2005
Companion.
You will receive a separate email from Sheridan Printing with details
about the final version's submission. (That email should include your
paper ID - but it is included here for your reference: pp25)

As for the poster: The poster boards are 8 x 4 feet landscape. You might
want to consider that for your layout...

Regards.
dirk

*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=

First reviewer's review:

>>> Summary of the submission <<<

This paper describes a workbench for Aspect Oriented Programming, which
supports easy work in terms of compiler technology and optimization
It is presented a brief but clear (at least for experts or semi expets)
explanation of Aspect Oriented Approach followed by a meaningfull description
of the abc architecture.
Variable binding as a mechanism to track the behavior of objects is presented
as innovative work.
Optimizacion in weaving step is also descibed.

>>> Evaluation <<<

+ Positive
Professional usefull work
Good presentation of general and detailed issues
Complete set of references
Easy to read

- Negative

--
*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*
Fourth reviewer's review:
          >>> Summary of the submission <<<
The aspect bench compiler - a new workbench for AOP research.
          >>> Evaluation <<<
Good incremental results in the AOP space. Well put together.
*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*=--=*